Today during Biology lesson with the most amazing, wonderful, capable, great, Mrs Tan Lai Lin (which in my opinion is one of the coolest and best bio teachers in RI) brought out a very good point.
Is the throughtrain programme effective?
The Throughtrain is this new implementation set two years ago to allow students of a particular school to enter into their affliated Junior College without the need to take O-levels, citing high stress levels and more effective learning as the reasons for this implementation.
Mrs Tan brought out a very good point, after handing out the bio assignments, that if we fail our A-levels or don’t do well, we only have a PSLE cert to show for it.
The thought horrified me. Of course I had always known that the PSLE cert thing would be a downside to throughtrain; if I failed my A-levels (touchwood) then I would drop straight down to P6 level. The thought reminded me of Who Wants To Be A Millionaire. The O-levels were a 32,000 safecheck, but now it’s been taken away. It’s definitely a con, but a pro would be at least we need not stress over the O-levels unneccesarily.
Or is it?
Mrs Tan commented that this was a gamble we had to take. The teachers in RI were all worried, because a lot of the students were getting complacent, and that they could get into RJC without a worry, so they need not do well in lower sec. This gamble was risky, and we needed to understand the risks. If we lost the blackjack, we would lose everything.
All or nothing. Could we make it?
I am very sure that not everyone can make it. It is a gamble that cannot support everyone, and a gamble that some students are sure to lose.
The question was, How many students would lose?
If more students lose every year, and more lose than gain, then we have to question ourselves, Is the throughtrain effective?
I have known friends who think the throughtrain programme has only good, not bad.
“My friends are all taking O-levels, but I can slack, so shiok!”
But then, your friends would have a backing to protect themselves in case anything went wrong. An O-level cert would still qualify for polytechnic courses.
Does the Ministry of Education have implementations that would give us some form of protection and immunity that we could use to at least make it past A-levels?
I am very certain that this education game, this gamble, is not one to be taken lightly, and if anything went wrong it would certainly be a gamble I could not afford.
True to ThroughTrain?
That is the question. Can we accept this new implementation, but with it, the sureness of complacency and arrogance and laziness, but without it, the added burden of stress and migraines, but also a protection and immunity that is worth more than lowered levels of blood pressure?
This is more than a case of lowered stress levels and lowered levels of systolic pressure over diastolic pressure… this is a case of whether we should choose the new programme because it brings new risks… new risks which may not spell GOOD.
Comments, anyone?